Blue Jays Need One More Win to Stay on Track

September 9, 2026 Abigail Cooper Comments Off

The Toronto Blue Jays have a chance to close out a valuable series victory when they meet the Athletics in Wednesday afternoon’s finale. With the postseason race tightening, this matchup carries extra weight for a club trying to hold its place in the American League wild-card chase.

Toronto enters at 73-73, one game behind the Cleveland Guardians for the final AL wild-card spot. With only 16 games left, the margin for error is shrinking quickly, which makes every remaining result feel amplified.

The game is scheduled for 3:05 p.m. ET and 12:05 p.m. PT at Sutter Health Park in West Sacramento. Fans in Canada can watch on Sportsnet.

Toronto Bounced Back After a Costly First Game

The Blue Jays opened the series with a frustrating 6-5 loss on Monday, a game in which defensive issues played a major role in the outcome. They answered well on Tuesday, taking a 4-2 win to even the series and keep their recent surge alive.

José Soriano gave Toronto exactly what it needed on the mound. He worked seven innings and surrendered just two solo home runs, allowing the Blue Jays to conserve their bullpen for the finale.

That mattered after Monday’s defeat forced six different pitchers into action. Soriano’s length on Tuesday gave the relief group a much-needed breather and improved Toronto’s chances of handling a shorter outing from the opener on Wednesday.

A win would give the Blue Jays their fourth straight series victory and help sustain the momentum they have built during a critical part of the schedule.

Toronto Plans Another Bullpen-Oriented Approach

Braydon Fisher will open the game for Toronto, making his ninth start of the season even though he has spent most of the year working out of the bullpen. The Blue Jays are again using him in a flexible role, expecting several relievers to cover the bulk of the innings behind him.

Fisher has posted a 3.20 ERA and a 1.24 WHIP across 70.1 innings, while striking out 68 hitters. The 26-year-old right-hander is also riding a run of five straight scoreless appearances.

Pitcher Role 2026 Workload Key Note
Braydon Fisher Blue Jays opener 70.1 innings, 3.20 ERA, 1.24 WHIP Has allowed no runs in five straight outings
Brady Basso Athletics starter 33.1 innings, 4.32 ERA, 1.41 WHIP None of his four starts has lasted beyond three innings

Fisher has already shown he can handle Oakland. In two March appearances against the Athletics, he retired every batter he faced over 2.1 combined innings. If he delivers again, Toronto’s bullpen should have a manageable path through the rest of the game.

Oakland Turns to a Short-Start Lefty

The Athletics will counter with left-hander Brady Basso, who is also unlikely to work deep into the night. He arrives with a 1-2 record, a 4.32 ERA, and a 1.41 WHIP over 33.1 innings this season.

Basso has made four starts, and none has gone longer than three innings. That makes this finale a strong candidate for a bullpen-heavy, matchup-driven finish on both sides.

Toronto may see an opening against an Oakland team that sits at 58-88 and owns one of the weakest run differentials in Major League Baseball. Still, the Athletics have already shown they can slow the Blue Jays down by taking the series opener.

Okamoto Keeps Delivering Power at the Right Time

Kazuma Okamoto has been a major source of offense during his first season in Major League Baseball. He homered in each of the first two games of the series, and his solo blast on Tuesday marked his 30th homer of the year.

That milestone made him the first Blue Jays rookie to reach 30 home runs. It also placed him among a small group of Japanese players to produce that many homers in a single MLB season, making his debut campaign even more notable.

Josh Smith added to the damage on Tuesday with a solo homer right before Okamoto went deep. It was Smith’s fifth home run since joining Toronto.

The Wild-Card Chase Leaves Little Room for Slippage

Tuesday’s win pulled Toronto back to .500 and kept the club one game behind Cleveland in the wild-card standings. The Blue Jays cannot clinch anything in this series, but a loss to a struggling opponent would make the road ahead much tougher.

The next stretch of games will matter just as much. After Thursday’s off day, Toronto returns home for six games against the Baltimore Orioles and Detroit Tigers, two more teams tied into the crowded wild-card picture.

  1. Finish the California trip with a series win over Oakland.
  2. Use the scheduled off day to reset before returning home.
  3. Prepare for six straight games against direct playoff rivals.

If the Blue Jays can finish the job on Wednesday, they will head home with both a series win and their postseason hopes still very much alive.